Showing posts with label early decision. Show all posts
Showing posts with label early decision. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 17, 2013

Early Decision Results and Challenges

Early Decision applicants received their admissions decisions via email last Thursday, December 11.  Letters were also mailed "snail mail" via USPS Priority or FedEx (depending upon the letter and the student's home address), so all applicants should now have the results of their hard work in hand.  And, truly, we do mean hard work.  Regardless of the decision, we can say with great admiration and wonder that we are impressed with each and every applicant's passion, involvement, and growth. Unfortunately, we cannot admit every applicant.

Undoubtedly, there were tears of joy and tears of disappointment. Having made decisions like these for years, we know that those who were not admitted will survive.  They will soon be able to separate themselves from the decision.  They may mourn the outcome for a time.  They may re-examine their college list.  And eventually, they will discover that they are going to be a great fit at another institution.  After all, in the formula of student + college, the student remains consistent.  Her path may change, depending upon the school she chooses, but she’s selected those schools on her list for good reasons.  By March, those not offered a space in the class will have other options, and by May one of those will soon become her top choice and her home for the next four years.

For those students deferred to be considered in the Regular Decision pool, there are more steps to take.  Applications of those deferred will be re-reviewed after February 1.  Between now and then, and as noted in their decision letter, applicants have the opportunity to add materials to their application file.  Semester or second trimester grades will be very important, but so will a letter from the students themselves.  A thoughtful, considered letter that helps to update us with new information and that goes beyond the 250 words you used to reply to our "Why Barnard" question may be the most important addition to the application.  For many students deferred in the past, this letter has made a big impact on our committee discussions.  Certainly, we would also welcome an additional letter of recommendation or a supplement of writing or other material.  Though, the voice of the student is often the most important addition in this stage.

Deferred students are often also experiencing difficult emotions upon the receipt of their letter.  It’s important for them to know that there isn’t and wasn’t anything wrong with them or their application.  In fact, we can easily say that we don’t defer huge numbers of applicants (usually 1/5 or 1/6 of the pool).  We don’t make these decisions lightly and we don’t defer students we don’t think would be competitive when reviewed in the regular pool.  The number of students we admit from those deferred differs from year to year, so it’s hard to give a sense of the chances that a student will ultimately be admitted.  However, we can assure those still awaiting a decision that we will read what you write very carefully.

Saturday, October 5, 2013

Should I apply Early Decision or Regular Decision?

Pumpkin spice lattes have made their annual reappearance. K-Mart has lined its shelves with the latest assortment of pirate and witch costumes. You know what this means: we are inching closer and closer to this year's new Early Decision deadline: November 1st.

As you may know already, Barnard offers two application deadlines: November 1st for Early Decision (ED) and January 1st for Regular Decision (RD). The key difference between the two is that ED is a binding commitment: if you're admitted, you are expected to come to Barnard. The benefit of ED is that you receive your decision - and therefore determine your future plans - by mid-December of your senior year. The benefit of RD is that you get some extra time to "play the field" and think about which college is really the best fit for you.

In other words, RD is dating. ED is marriage.

So how do you decide which of these plans is right for you?? When making the ED versus RD choice, there are two major factors to consider:

Finances
Are you applying for financial aid? If so, you should make sure to understand Barnard's financial aid policy before making the commitment of ED. For instance, it's important to know that, while our financial aid packages meet 100% of demonstrated financial need, we do not offer merit-based scholarships. So it's crucial to have an idea as to whether or not your family will qualify for need-based aid and, if not, how they will make the cost work.

It's worth taking an evening to plug some thoughtful, well-informed financial data into our Net Price Calculator, which will spit out an estimate of what you can expect to pay, given the financial aid package you would receive at Barnard. If, after this exercise, you feel like you need to compare our final financial aid package with schools, especially those that offer merit-based scholarships, then ED is not the right fit for you.

Love
Aside from finances, it all boils down to one question: will you be happier within Barnard's gates than at any other college? If you have done your research on Barnard, have thought about what you would decide on 5/1, should you apply and be admitted to all colleges on your list, and the answer to this question is still yes, *and* you have worked through the finances (see above), then go for it! It sounds like ED is perfect for you.

If there is any doubt in your mind about attending Barnard - maybe there is another college equally high on your list, or maybe you just haven't finished doing your research about us yet - then it doesn't make sense to make the commitment of ED. Barnard is a complex place and, for some students, it can take time to understand and fall in love. If you're not there yet, then give yourself the freedom of RD. We're confident you'll come around by January 1st.